Hello Romaniac, thank you for your message.
I was very much expecting this response. I almost invited it I suppose.
And yes you are right - it might be arrogant in one sense, and as I admitted, it might be US/UK centric, but I'll make my case:
First, I COMPLETELY agree with your statement about learning the language - don’t get me wrong, I am learning AND I do get by in everyday life, otherwise I would feel VERY isolated.
The FULLY part takes time though and it seems the driving test requires fully and then some more...
In the US it’s different - but it might be unfair to compare this situation to the US as it's a country of immigrants. In NYC for instance, you can take the test in more than a dozen languages. But again, NYC is a melting pot and even special in the US.
It's a shame that UK is doing the same - I would say the alternative would be making a test for people who have proven clean record in their country of residence (that have similar driving laws) to be able to take a test of ESSENTIALS. I can't begin to describe to you some of the absolutely mundane minutae that is required to learn for the Italian test...many of which you will never ever use or need in actual practical everyday life. I’m sorry to say this but I cannot imagine some folks in Italy actually passing this test (many elderly renewing for instance?) I can say half the study guide is full of things you will probably forget the moment after you pass the test.
As far as driving being a privilege not a right - well yes, but to make it difficult doesn’t help the society either. You can say the same for the internet, but then good luck having a functioning society.
If it’s even difficult for your own citizens to take the test then maybe your should review your process no?
(BTW - this goes for MANY MANY thing in Italy as I am finding out. The red tape here is maddening at times and you can wonder why even Italians lament their system.)
Another point - my colleagues at the company I worked for the past year ALL spoke English - Why? Because it’s an international company doing international business in an international city.
(I don’t even get to learn Italian by working at an Italian company next to Italians, ironically. But of course even more ironic is that if they did require Italian, I might not have gotten the job.
But that would be a case of “wanting to have your cake and eat it too” I suppose.)
Yes I chose to live in Italy, but many people might end up here because of a spouse or other situations where it was not their first choice but it is their reality at the moment. Mine was a bit of both, but I find myself very fortunate and happy to be here, and intend to integrate as I want to do many things that require knowing the language to a certain degree.
So to reiterate- I am learning Italian - I can get by fine...but it is nowhere near the level you would need to negotiate this test.
When I told my local driving school of my situation she looked at me like I was crazy. As in ...don't even try.
And last...English and several other languages WERE offered before and for some reason it stopped.
I don’t know why…or I know all too well:
“That’s Italy!”
I'll take the good with the bad
Cheers!